
So, Dick Cheney decided to say on Fox News Sunday that waterboarding worked. Two dossiers he specifically had declassified appear to show that people talked more after waterboarding.
The problem isn't that it may in some cases work. The problem is all of the other reasons:
- It leads to false information.
- It can be used no matter how "necessary" when someone in power has an agenda.
- It puts our troops in harm's way.
- It makes us exactly what our enemies say we are. If we lose our identity, how can we ever say we've won?
The problem, Cheney, isn't that it doesn't work, although the information is brought forth by people under duress, so by default it must be thoroughly vetted (Remember your "link between Iraq and 9/11?"). The problem, is that it makes us unsafe and immoral. It's hard to take the high road when you're dragging a prisoner behind you.












